Part 1: Clan Divisions
In this three part series we will look into the different ways that a gaming community can be divided. Along with addressing the problem with these three different ways that a community can be separated, we will also provide a way to “solve” this problem (or make it less of a problem).
If you have played any form on online game, whether it is a MMO, FPS, or RPG, you have probably encountered or have been a part of an online clan (or guild). While the formation of a guild is not the main problem, given that the reason for most guilds forming is innocent enough. Most clans start off with a common belief or interest and just want a way to communicate with each other. However, it is multiple guilds interaction with one another that can cause a problem.
The Problem
Guilds interacting with each other can yield, for the most part, 3 different results; the clans could relate with each other and an alliance could form, mutual indifference, or the two clans can be too different to coexist and a rivalry can form. The main problem with clans interacting with each other is the chance that a rivalry could form.
When clan rivalry forms, they two guilds can admit that they have their problems and go on their separate ways just ignoring each other. However, they could figure that there isn’t room for both of their clans in the game (queue old western movie here) and the members could go at each other’s throats. This can involve ganking (“unfairly” killing low or under geared characters) or obscenities and just plan being immature or rude (possibly publicly ruining the two clan’s public image).
The Solution
The solution can be easy if the two clan leaders can find somewhere neutral to meet or talk about the guilds differences. For example, my guild in World of Warcraft was having problems with another ICC raiding guild. There was some debate over whether or not one of my guild members was unfairly denied an item. After this my guilds became furious and quit from the group and were frankly rude to their members. As I was on vacation at the time, it was a week or two later before I could talk to the other guild leader. Basically I have ___ tips to any clan/clan leaders when dealing with a situation like this:
1.) Understand their side of the story.
2.) Try to compromise or state your side of the story.
3.) If you can come to an agreement (i.e. not behaving like idiots) you do not have to be friends with each other.
4.) If you do not come with an agreement try to state that you would like if your clans do not interact at all (i.e. do not publically make fun, or criticize each other).
Conclusion
I sincerely hope that this article will help some clans in the future. I am in no way against clans, I happen to think that clans are a very important part of an online community. If differences or arguments do not cause too much drama, they can be a very beneficial social experience. If you have any suggestions please leave a comment below, or post in the forums.
Next in this series Divisions in Gaming: Genre Divisions.
